BAILII is celebrating 24 years of free online access to the law! Would you consider making a contribution?
No donation is too small. If every visitor before 31 December gives just £1, it will have a significant impact on BAILII's ability to continue providing free access to the law.
Thank you very much for your support!
 |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] | |
Crown Court for Northern Ireland Decisions |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> Crown Court for Northern Ireland Decisions >> McKenna, R v [2007] NICC 43 (23 November 2007) URL: http://www.bailii.org/nie/cases/NICC/2007/43.html Cite as: [2007] NICC 43 |
||
[New search] [Printable RTF version] [Help]
Ref: TREF5993
TREACY J
[1] Gerard McKenna you have pleaded guilty to the manslaughter of Sean Patrick Mimnagh on 17 July 2005. [2] The court was furnished with a three page document, which Mr Mateer QC informed the court was an agreed document, setting out in some detail the circumstances of the offence. This document was also opened in full and accordingly I propose only to summarise the material facts. [3] On 17 July 2005 in the early hours of the morning some time around 2.15 am, Sean Patrick Mimnagh, aged 21, was knocked down and killed by a Vauxhall car driven by the accused at the car park of the Matrix nightclub at the Glengannon Hotel, near Dungannon. [4] The defendant and his passenger and friend Paul McKenna had arrived by car at the hotel some 15 minutes or so before the fatal collision which would therefore have placed their time of arrival some time around 2.00 am. Both had been drinking in a number of licensed premises prior to their arrival. They were unsuccessful in gaining admittance to the Matrix nightclub which by that stage had closed. [5] They then approached a small group of people who were standing in the car park in an area usually used by people waiting for taxis. Two of the proprietors of the Matrix club, Mr Graham and Mr Rowan, whilst leaving the car park saw a number of girls and young men. Close by were two other young men both wearing glasses one of whom had spoken to Mr Graham earlier. These two appear to have been the accused and his friend Paul McKenna. A short time later whilst returning by car on the public road along the side of the car park Mr Graham and Mr Rowan observed a scuffle involving some of the people they had earlier seen on their way out. They drove round to the main driveway of the hotel/nightclub complex and stopped the car to intervene. From this vantage point Mr Rowan could see three persons involved in kicking a person on the ground – this was Paul McKenna being kicked. He shouted at the attackers and they stopped and the men involved walked away. [6] Mr Rowan satisfied himself that Paul McKenna was all right. He then got back into his car intending to drive off. It was at this point that the accused's car was observed coming from the main car park at speed. It crossed the thin grass central reservation dividing the Matrix car park from the main driveway where he had been parked. He could see it stop beside Paul McKenna – who had been lying on the ground having been kicked. [7] Mr Ferry, a taxi driver who had been booked to take Mr Mimnagh and his friends home, arrived roughly around the same time as Mr Rowan and Mr Graham's car pulled into the hotel driveway. His evidence indicates that after the fighting came to an end – that is after Mr Rowan's intervention – all of his passengers had got into the taxi except for Mr Mimnagh. He looked across to the car park and could see Paul McKenna looking for his glasses with some girls appearing to help him. [8] He also describes the defendant's car appearing from the area where it had been parked in front of the main hotel. He describes the car "taking off" with wheels spinning and driving very hard around the car park. He heard the accused – the driver – shout to one of the girls to "fuck off" and heard the beginning of a sentence beginning with the words "I am going to get ….".The defendant had driven round to his friend Paul McKenna who then got into the vehicle. [9] Another witness – one of the girls heard "I am going get one of these bastards" and still another heard "See them bastards, I'm going to get them" or "I'm going to get them bastards". [10] The deceased Sean Mimnagh was the only one of the party of four due to leave in Mr Ferry's taxi who had not reached it by this stage. The taxi man could see the deceased begin to walk across from the Matrix in the general direction of his taxi. As Sean Mimnagh made his way across the car park the accused at the same time left the area from the rear of the Matrix travelling in a route towards Sean Mimnagh. [11] Part of the incident was captured on the CCTV from the Matrix complex. An enhanced image produced by an expert video enhancer reproduces the start position of the car from where it is seen in one of the cameras, through the collision scene as indicated by the bloodstaining left at the scene and on to the exit point where it left the car park. This confirms that the route taken was a deviation from the direct line of travel to the exit point – initially to the driver's right and then to the left. [12] The evidence indicates that the deceased jumped to his right on the approach of the defendant but a collision occurred such that he was knocked to the ground, resulting in the front driver's wheel passing over the deceased's head causing injuries from which he died very rapidly. [13] The accused continued to drive on and left the scene. [14] The defendant's car was reported seen crashed into the gable wall of a barn about three miles away. Martin McKenna the defendant's cousin who lives locally contacted police after the later press release had gone out to say he had towed the defendants car from the crash site to a shed. He also said that the defendant had been dropped off in Dungannon intending to go to Athlone for motor bike racing the following day. [15] The accused returned to Northern Ireland after he learned that the deceased had in fact died and came voluntarily to the police. On being charged he stated "I didn't mean to kill anybody". [16] During his interviews the accused claimed he had drunk the equivalent of 4 or 4½ pints over the course of the evening at a number of licensed premises, but that he was at the relevant time nevertheless fit to drive. When the row developed and his friend was being attacked on the ground he maintained that he was scared and he decided to get the car to get his friend Paul and he drove off. He maintained that he didn't realise he had hit or driven over anyone. I must say I find that aspect of his account highly improbable. He stated that he was in a panic. He was asked about the details just before he drove off and he said that he was aware that the girls were trying to help Paul and that at that time the boys who had attacked him were no longer beside Paul. He told police he had driven along the main road in the direction of Ballygally but turned off towards Eglish then Greystone and then crashed the car. He then got a lift from a passing motorist to his cousin's house and his cousin pulled the car out of the ditch for him and towed it to his garage. He then told police that rather than go home he decided to go to see motor bike racing so he got dropped off in Dungannon. [17] He was able to give quite a detailed account of his movements and of the incident leading to the scuffle although thereafter his powers of recollection mystifyingly fade. He remembered driving over the kerb to get into the Matrix car park – the car was banging going over it – he picked up Paul and drove he thought in first gear in a high rev. He said that when he took off he was spinning as hard as he could later telling police that he had 3 or 4 years experience of stock car racing. He told the police that he didn't know he had hit anyone until the next day when he got a phone call from a friend around 12 or 1 pm. [18] He initially denied saying he was going to get anyone but a little later in the interview said that he wasn't sure about that, he didn't know whether he did say that or not. It is however now accepted that he did express such hostility. [19] After the Crown had opened the case I enquired as to whether there was a personal family statement from the deceased's family. It appears that they were unaware that they had an opportunity to contribute in this fashion. When informed they indicated that they wished to avail of the opportunity to make a personal statement. It was agreed that this should be shown to the defence in advance and then (in the absence of any valid objection) to the court. I enquired of the defence as to whether in those circumstances they wished to make their plea then or to defer it until after the personal statement had been received and was informed by Mr Gallagher QC on behalf of the defendant that they preferred to defer the plea until the statement was available. Everyone agreed that this was an appropriate course to adopt. [20] When I was informed that the family wanted to make a personal statement it was agreed that it might also be helpful for the family to be provided with the many references that had been furnished on the accused's behalf as well as the pre-sentence report. This course commended itself because whilst it would not lessen the grief of the family they would at least have seen some of the material that the court would take into account in sentencing the accused and might therefore have a fuller appreciation of the accused and of the sentence. [21] I also considered that, in the absence of some medical or other cogent reason against it that the personal statement prepared by the family should be shown to the accused. This I understand has been done. [22] The personal statement was in the following terms:"It's hard to write on paper what Sean meant to each of us, he was loved so much by all the family. He was a mummy's boy, her only son and our only brother, He would have went out with friends but was a homebird at heart. He was quiet, modest and easy going and would never get in a panic. Me and Sean were wild close we were always together. I loved him so much. We were like best friends, We always went out together. I didn't go out with him that night but was waiting for him to come home to hear all the craic of his night out but he never made it back. The last time we seen Sean he was in great form and was wearing the new clothes he had bought
earlier that day. That was only the second time Sean had been to the Glengannon. Sean died on mummy's birthday. He always went into mummy's bedroom when he came in at night it didn't matter what time it was to get a cigarette out of her bag, mum used to give off and tell him to buy his own but she always gave them to him, and now that he's gone it's one of the things she misses the most. He used to say to mum "any money ma" and she would have slipped him money and tried to hide it from Catherine and me, mum spoiled Sean because he was the only boy in the house and Catherine and I would have nagged her about him being spoiled but looking back now we both spoiled him too. We will never get
over loosing Sean, during the day it is easier to get on
with things but nighttimes are hardest. That's when we think of things the most, mum is on sleeping tablets as she cant sleep at night. She's also on antidepressants since it happened. I would often dream about Sean and wake up and expect him to be there then it just hits you all over again that he's not coming home. It's coming up to Christmas and we dread it, Christmas is a time for family and our family is empty without Sean. Sean was so young, only 21 he had his whole life in front of him, so full of life. Sean will never have the chance to experience life, having a girlfriend, getting married and having children. His life was cut so short so needlessly and pointlessly by someone else's doing. Sean worked with his dad as a. stonemason after he left school, he went on to train as a plasterer., he was doing this up until he died. He played hurling when he was at school. He played for his county team Tyrone, he was planning on going back to hurling but never got the chance. He used to love fishing as well, he would head out for the day on
his own and fish all day. Our lives will never be the same without Sean, it's hard to accept what's happened, we still expect to see him coming through the door. It's hard to move on, we've been waiting two and a half years for justice to be done for Sean. Sean suffered a horrible death. We hope and pray that he's at peace now and that justice will be done.
Written by Natalie Mimnagh age 21 on behalf of Teresa Mimnagh (Sean's mummy) and Catherine Mimnagh (Sean's sister)"
Basis of plea
[23] An agreed document setting out the basis of the defendant's plea to manslaughter was handed into court and it was in the following terms:1. The Defendant pleads guilty to manslaughter on the basis of committing an unlawful act causing the deceased's death (unlawful act manslaughter, otherwise known as dangerous act manslaughter).
2. The Defendant did not intend to kill the deceased nor did he intend to cause the deceased grievous bodily harm.
3. The mens rea necessary for the commission of unlawful act manslaughter is recklessness on the part of the Defendant in subjecting the deceased to the risk of harm or putting him in fear of harm.
VENNA (1970) QB421
SPRATT (1991) 1 WLR 1073
CHURCH (1960) 1 QB 59
DPP v NEWBURY (1977) AC 500
GRAY v BARR(1971)2QB 554"
